By Mijal Grinberg / Haaretz
The Bedouin sector is due to submit a counter-report to the state’s report on discrimination to the United Nations, as part of its demand that the international body help fight systemic discrimination against them.
When the Justice Ministry submits its report in August, social groups will submit documents criticizing the state report and elucidating state discrimination against the Bedouin sector.
Israel is a signatory to the International Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Racial Discrimination, and periodically submits reports on advancements in the arena.
The state will submit its next report in Geneva in August. The Negev Coexistence Forum, in conjunction with Physicians for Human Rights, prepared a counter-report pointing out failings in the state report.
Services: According to the state report, in Bedouin towns citizens “receive services at a level equal to every other citizen in the state.” However, the counter-report states that there are six Bedouin towns recognized as “permanent communities” and one city, Rahat. There is no public transportation in any of the towns. Rahat has 40,000 residents, one post office, one bank and no public library. The towns do not have any of these services, unlikes Jewish towns with an equal number of residents, according to the Adva Center.
Land: The state report writes that “members of the Bedouin community were given more land per person than any other population.” The counter-report reveals a different picture. There are currently 45 Bedouin villages, among which only 10 are legally recognized. Despite the more than a hundred Jewish agricultural villages in the Negev, there was, until recently, not a single Bedouin agricultural village. The two Bedouin villages now defined as “agricultural” were not given proper water rations or crop rations, according to former Bedouin Administration chairman and current Rahat city adviser Eli Atzmon.
Haya Noah, of the Negev Coexistence Forum, said land allocation in one village was 10,000 dunams for 1,000 people, compared to Jewish communities who are each given thousands of dunams for fewer than one hundred families.
Water: The state reports that since 1997, the sedentary population in unrecognized villages have had access to water. However, according to the counter-report, the Bedouin Administration claims that, in 2003, the water committee converged only four times, and approved only six out of 80 requests for water. Bedouin say that in certain cases it took a year to hook up a water system and at a cost of NIS 10,000.
Religion: Israeli law grants its citizens access to holy sites. According to the Bedouin report, the city of Be’er Sheva refused to call the only mosque in the city a prayer center or a Muslim community center, as recommended by the High Court of Justice. A city spokesperson said the building could not be used as a place of worship, but as a museum, as it hasn’t been used as a mosque for over 60 years.